GOOD AND BAD ALTERNATIVES FOR HOMEOWNERS HAVING DIFFICULTIES MAKING MORTGAGE PAYMENTS:
Do Nothing -
If a homeowner does nothing, they will most likely
will lose their home at a foreclosure auction. This also has a major negative impact on the homeowner's credit report. The homeowner's ability to obtain future credit for homes, cars, and other purchases will be severely damaged for years. Doing nothing is the MOST common reaction and the WORST thing a homeowner can do.
Discounted payoff -
In some cases the lender might be agreeable
to a full payoff where they award a discount. This is often the
most cost
effective option for the homeowner. Instead of having to pay the
full face principal on the loan and continue make interest payments,
they can
negotiate to pay only a portion of the outstanding balance. Obviously, the
downside is that if the homeowner is having trouble making only the
monthly payments, they
might not have the ability to pay off the loan. However, this option is
so attractive and the discount can be so substantial in some cases that
it is worth getting
creative to afford this option. Some possible sources are:
- Withdraw money from your 401K as a hardship distribution - A homeowner is allowed to make a 401K withdrawal without penalty to avoid a foreclosure.
For more information from the IRS, visit Hardship Distributions.
- Credit cards and hard money lenders - In some cases it might
make sense to accomplish the payoff using this option. As an example,
let's say the
lender is offering a 90% discount on a 16% interest loan and the
homeowner's credit card APR is 18%. The payoff discount being offered is
attractive so it makes
sense to use a credit card for the payoff. In addition, the homeowner
has now turned secured debt into unsecured debt ensuring they will not
lose their home.
It is not common to get such a heavy discount, but some lenders will
offer them. Most mortgage lenders will not accept credit cards as a form
of payment, but
some credit cards offer checks that, in most cases, can be used as a
regular check.
Payoff/Refinance - Completely pay off the entire loan amount plus
any default amounts and fees. Typically this is accomplished by
a refinance of
the mortgage loan. The new loan is usually at a higher interest rate,
plus there may be a prepayment penalty because of the recent default.
This option
is available if the home is worth more than the payoff amount of the
delinquent loan and it assumes the homeowners still have reasonably good
credit scores.
Reinstatement -
Paying the entire past-due amount on the mortgage loan (all missed payments, plus interest, attorney fees, late fees, taxes,
and other fees). This requires the lender's approval, particularly if foreclosure has actually started.
Loan Modification -
Work with the mortgage lender to rearrange
the conditions of the loan (add years to the loan term or increase the
amount of
monthly payments to repay the delinquent payments and other costs over the
remaining life of the loan). This may allow the homeowner to get caught
up without having to refinance the entire loan. To qualify, you must
prove to the lender you have fixed the problem that caused the late
payment. This requires lender approval.
Forbearance -
The lender might agree to a temporary repayment plan
based on the homeowner's financial situation. The lender may even be
able to
provide a temporary payment reduction or suspension of payments.
Information will be required by the lender to show that you are able
to meet the new payment plan requirements. This requires lender
approval.
New Second Mortgage (Partial claim) -
In some cases, the mortgage
lender may give the homeowner an additional mortgage, secured by the
home.
All of the new loan proceeds are used to bring the 1st mortgage up to
date. From that point on, the homeowner must make payments on both the
original and new loans. Depending on the mortgage lender/investor, this
option might be fairly easy to obtain but must be requested by the
homeowner.
Deed in Lieu of Foreclosure/Quit-Claim Deed -
Give the property
to the lender instead of having the lender take the property by
foreclosure.
While less damaging than a foreclosure, this will still impact the
borrower's credit score. Banks generally require that the home be well
maintained, all mortgage payments and taxes be paid current, and that the
home be in good general condition. This requires lender approval.
Rent the property -
This option works best when the monthly rental payment is equal to the full mortgage payment.
It can also work if the homeowner has the ability to cover the shortage.
To use this option, the loan must be brought current. This requires lender approval.
Sale - There are two types of home sales:
If the property IS
worth at least enough to pay off the mortgage
debt, the homeowner may sell home without lender approval through a
conventional home sale.
This is the best method for protecting a homeowner's credit score, but
it becomes more difficult to do as the number of missed mortgage payments
increases.
If the property IS NOT
worth enough to pay off the entire mortgage debt, a short sale,
also known as a pre-foreclosure sale, can be negotiated with your lender by a real estate professional.
This requires lender approval and may affect the homeowner's credit score.